CN 11-5366/S     ISSN 1673-1530
“风景园林,不只是一本期刊。”

利用众包视觉感知方法促进公众视角融入城市设计决策

Promoting the Integration of Public Perspective into Urban Design Decision-Making Based on Crowdsourced Visual Perception Method

  • 摘要:
    目的 众包视觉感知数据及分析方法凭借高效性、代表性和低成本优势,已成为城市建成环境研究的重要工具。通过解析众包视觉感知方法的作用路径与效能特征,系统揭示其促进公众视角融入城市设计决策的理论逻辑,为人本导向的城市设计实践提供科学且实用的方法论支撑。
    方法 选取5篇基于众包视觉感知方法的城市设计文献作为研究案例,围绕数据收集、数据分析和方案生成3个城市设计的关键环节,讨论众包视觉感知数据及分析方法促进公众视角融入城市设计决策的作用机制。
    结果 在数据收集阶段,通过训练基于深度学习技术的视觉感知推理模型对微观尺度城市公众视觉感知进行自动量化,提供低成本、广覆盖的公众视角的需求洞察;解析公众视觉感知与建成环境要素的关联可为制定科学的设计干预策略和设计目标提供依据;在方案生成阶段,基于众包视觉感知数据训练的生成式人工智能模型将公众的感知偏好自动转换为直观且可视化的设计语言,为城市设计决策的方案生成阶段提供了一种新型人机协同手段。
    结论 揭示了利用众包视觉感知方法促进公众视角融入城市设计决策的路径与潜力,提升了设计决策的科学性和包容性,但其应用仍面临数据质量、公众动态体验捕捉及技术透明度等挑战。

     

    Abstract:
    Objective Cities, as the core carriers of human civilization, have spatial forms and physical environments that profoundly affect the quality of residents’ life and well-being. In micro-scale urban settings—such as streets and squares closely tied to daily life — interactions between people and urban spaces are most direct and frequent, with design quality directly determining residents’ comfort and convenience. Urban design, as a key practice in shaping these spaces, has evolved into a human-centered, participatory process of placemaking. However, in practice, time and cost constraints often lead decisions to overly rely on professional judgment, making it challenging to fully reflect public needs. Urban perception captures the public’s preferences for specific urban environments and their experiential feedback on spatial demands. Rooted in environmental psychology, this concept views human perception as a vital link in human-environment interactions, bridging spatial design and human experience while playing a central role in shaping urban environments. Among sensory modalities, visual perception stands out as the dominant dimension due to its primacy, making it a core focus of urban perception studies. Examining urban perception reveals authentic public needs — though lacking professional design expertise to propose specific solutions, the public’s sensory experiences and perceptual feedback effectively highlight real demands, providing critical input for design decisions. Thus, understanding and integrating public urban perception not only enhances design responsiveness to user needs but also fosters a harmonious balance of functional efficiency and humanistic care. Crowdsourced visual perception data and analysis methods, with their advantages of efficiency, broad representativeness, and low cost, have become key methodological tools in urban built environment research. However, existing research has yet to systematically explore how these methods effectively facilitate the integration of public perspectives into urban design decision-making, leaving their pathways and methodological efficacy in need of further refinement and synthesis. This research aims to dissect the pathways and efficacy features of crowdsourced visual perception methods, systematically uncovering the theoretical logic and mechanisms by which they promote public involvement in urban design decisions, thereby providing a scientifically robust and practical methodological foundation for human-centered urban design practices.
    Methods The research employs a case study approach, analyzing multiple urban research papers focused on Tokyo, Japan, that utilize crowdsourced visual perception methods. It systematically investigates how these methods, across key urban design decision-making stages — data collection, data analysis, and scheme generation — facilitate the deep integration of public perspectives into design decisions through specific pathways and mechanisms. The study particularly emphasizes micro-scale urban design.
    Results In the data collection phase, perception inference models trained with crowdsourced visual perception data and deep learning efficiently compute and evaluate perceptions of micro-scale urban scenes, offering designers an automated, low-cost means to gain insights into public perspectives early in a project. This approach addresses the limitations of traditional methods in data coverage and cost, significantly enhancing the breadth and representativeness of public perspectives in design decisions. From the perspective of integration, crowdsourcing breaks the traditional top-down data acquisition barrier, enabling ordinary citizens to indirectly contribute to the informational foundation of urban design by sharing individual perceptions. This shift not only increases data diversity and inclusivity but also empowers the public to express needs and preferences in the early stages of design decision-making. In the data analysis phase, statistical methods establish quantitative models linking built environment factors with visual perception evaluations, uncovering the interaction mechanisms between public preferences and built environment elements. These methods identify key factors significantly affecting visual perception and determine optimal parameter ranges for design interventions via regression analysis, providing a scientific basis for formulating design strategies and goals. Notably, nonlinear analysis methods capture complex relationships with greater precision. In the scheme generation phase, integrating crowdsourced perception data with generative AI transforms public perceptual preferences into intuitive, visualized design language, introducing a novel human-machine collaboration approach to urban design decision-making. The visualized outputs of AI-generated schemes offer a transparent and comprehensible negotiation basis for subsequent decisions, facilitating stakeholder interpretation and participation. Within this technology, the Stable Diffusion (SD) model outperforms GAN in generation quality, diversity, and flexibility.
    Conclusion The research uses visual perception as a lens to integrate public perspectives, exploring the role of crowdsourced visual perception in micro-scale urban design decision-making through detailed case studies. It systematically examines the pathways and mechanisms by which this approach embeds public input, highlighting its applicability, technical implementation, and inherent limitations. The findings offer a robust framework for incorporating public perspectives into micro-scale urban design decisions while laying a theoretical groundwork to advance the scientific rigor and inclusivity of the design decision-making process.

     

/

返回文章
返回